• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to footer

Dawn Brookes

Author

  • Home
  • About
  • Books
    • Rachel Prince Mysteries
    • The Rachel Prince Mysteries Box Sets
    • Carlos Jacobi
      • Body in the Woods
      • The Bradgate Park Murders
    • Lady Marjorie Snellthorpe Mysteries
      • Death of a Blogger
      • Murder at the Opera House
      • Murder in the Highlands
    • Nursing Memoirs
      • Hurry up Nurse! Book 1
      • Hurry up Nurse 2: London calling | Book 2
      • Hurry up Nurse 3: More adventures in the life of a student nurse|Book 3
    • Audiobooks
  • Books Show
  • Contact
  • Free Book
  • Events/Courses
  • Philanthropy
  • Press
  • Rachel Prince Mysteries
    • A Cruise to Murder
    • Deadly Cruise
    • Killer Cruise
    • Dying to Cruise
    • A Christmas Cruise Murder
    • Murderous Cruise Habit
    • Honeymoon Cruise Murder
    • A Murder Mystery Cruise
    • Hazardous Cruise
    • Captain’s Dinner Cruise Murder
  • Carlos Jacobi
    • Body in the Woods
    • The Bradgate Park Murders
  • Lady Marjorie Snellthorpe Mysteries
    • Death of a Blogger
    • Murder at the Opera House
    • Murder in the Highlands
  • Nursing Memoirs
    • Hurry up Nurse! Book 1
    • Hurry up Nurse 2: London calling | Book 2
    • Hurry up Nurse 3: More adventures in the life of a student nurse|Book 3
  • The Rachel Prince Mysteries Box Sets
  • Children’s Books
    • Suki Seal & the Plastic Ring
    • Gerry the One-Eared Cat
    • Danny the Caterpillar
    • Ava & Oliver Series
      • Ava & Oliver’s Bonfire Night Adventure
      • Ava & Oliver’s Christmas Nativity Adventure
    • Miracles of Jesus Series
      • Jesus Feeds a Big Crowd!
      • Jesus heals a man on a stretcher
  • My Readers Top 20 Books Read in 2021

Writing conventions

Cozy Mystery Writing Conventions

October 16, 2020

Genre Fiction

I’m a mystery writer with my fiction falling into the cozy/cosy crime niche. I’ve now published seven books in one series with an eighth on the way. Cosy mysteries and the majority of detective novels fall into the category of writing known as genre fiction and on the whole, follow a defined set of conventions.

Agatha Christie Monument

These conventions/rules developed out of the Golden Age of Crime novels. Authors such as Arthur Conan Doyle, Margery Allingham, Dorothy L Sayers and Agatha Christie created the widely recognised genre. The cosy mystery has evolved over the past few decades as new writers attempt to stretch boundaries, although many still adhere to the Decalogue or ten commandments described by Knox in 1929. 

Escapist Literature

I admit to being challenged by proponents of literary fiction and literary debate such as Albert Camus, but I prefer to write books to enable people to escape from the reality of life. This is one of the reasons I write books where the criminal is always found and justice is served. The popularity of genre fiction could highlight the need for people to feel safe while – at least in terms of crime fiction – being given the opportunity to experience vicarious excitement. The excitement comes through readers exercising their brains to solve the puzzle, working alongside the sleuth. 

As a former nurse, I studied Maslow’s Hierarchy of Human Needs in great detail. He described the need to feel safe in the hierarchy. He postulated human beings needed to satisfy certain needs in order to grow, mentally and physically. Maslow’s definition of safety was more about protection from external elements. Such safety requires a person to have shelter and security of body and mind; order in the world outside; laws that reinforced safety; stability in work and finance and freedom from fear.

Escapist literature does help people to remove themselves from the harsh realities of the world for a time. 

Writing within Genre Conventions

A major challenge with formula writing is that of staying within genre constraints while adding enough variation to make the work unique and interesting. Lethem, (2007) argues that no work is completely original and Eliot (1920) stated that ‘mature poets steal’. King Solomon complains even in Biblical times that ‘there is nothing new under the sun’ (Ecclesiastes 1:9). 

Genre Conventions

When a reader sits down to read a book based on a formula they are familiar with such as a crime novel. They and the writer will have been influenced by previous books. Julia Kristeva called such a relationship within the academic world, intertextuality but the same applies to reading and writing formula fiction. The reader expects to find new layers within each novel, without which, they will feel dissatisfied. 

Genre, or formula writing doesn’t claim complete originality but there still needs to be something different about each work to keep it interesting. Bloom (1997) suggests that authors can be original although his text spends a lot of space arguing why it might not be.

Opponents of Formula Fiction

Stories falling within formulaic modes are commonly defined by those who oppose such literature as ‘sub-literate (as opposed to literature), entertainment (as opposed to serious literature), popular art (as opposed to fine art), lowbrow culture (as opposed to highbrow)…’ (Cawelti).

Describing formula writing in this way denigrates its artistic ability to fulfil a need within the human being to find pleasure through reading such works, and denies its own purpose and justification. 

Pacing

One of the main issues authors have with writing genre fiction – or any fiction for that matter – is pacing. 

Cosy mysteries tend to be written at a meandering pace where the plot unfolds gradually in an enclosed space, for example an English country village or, in my case, on board a cruise ship. 

Some crime fiction is written in this style but suspense thrillers generally require more tension. Writing the first Carlos Jacobi mystery has involved a change of pacing for me as a writer. I’ve had to think about phrasing and creating hooks at the beginning of the work. On reflection, this applies to all fiction and all writers improve over time.

New Series: Carlos Jacobi PI

For me, opting to remain true to crime fiction, but attempting to write a grittier series has been a new experience. Many people believe that the original detective fiction novel formula began with Edgar Allen Poe.

Carlos Jacobi PI

In Body in the Woods, there is one character (brother-in-law of protagonist) who is deliberately long-winded as he is the sort of person who goes into the minutiae of detail even in normal conversation. He is a scientist and a bit of an anorak. My challenge was, how to incorporate these characteristics into the story so that the reader understands his long-windedness is deliberate. I wanted the reader to be able to relate to this person as someone they might know in real-life. 

Valuing Genre Fiction

With my new series – although more gritty than the Rachel Prince Mysteries – I’ve remained true to my ethical stance as a writer that not all crime fiction needs to be gory. Neither does it have to include bad language nor explicit sex. I believe the challenge for me as an author is to create page-turning work without the use of sensationalist shock value. There is as much room in the market for clean crime today as there was when the forerunners of cozy crime penned their works.

Cawelti’s work has had the most profound influence on me as a writer in that it has reinforced my belief that writing genre fiction is just as valuable as writing literary fiction. He argues that formula literature (which crime fiction fits into) has a cultural value and I believe such literature fulfils an important function in human psychology. 

What about you?

Footer

GET IN TOUCH

Contact

 

Connect With Me

  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Follow Me on Bookbub

Dawn Brookes

Affiliate Links

Dawn Brookes is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to generate an income stream by including affiliate links to Amazon. If anyone orders a product after visiting Amazon via one of these links, the affiliate receives a small referral fee from Amazon. Links to the Alliance of Independent Authors membership website also include an affiliate code.

My Book Progress

Murder at a Wimbledon Mansion
Phase:First Draft
100%

Follow/Like me on Facebook

Privacy

Privacy Policy

Join Alliance of Independent Authors

Alliance of Independent Authors /

Copyright © 2023 · Dawn Brookes All rights reserved

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are as essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
SAVE & ACCEPT